What's in a title?

Published: 13 Aug 2018 Average Rating: 4 / 5 Print

Author: Tim Cummins

A few years ago, IACCM explored the range of job titles involved in performing the end to end commercial and contracting process, both buy and sell side. We found approximately 65 titles in common use. More recently, we undertook a more comprehensive examination of our member database and found well in excess of 200 titles.

What does this diversity tell us? Is it that there are wide variations in job roles, with perhaps a trend to increased specialism? Is it (as some would contend) that there are few similarities in the work undertaken in different industries or geographies? Or perhaps it is just a matter of preference and taste within individual organizations ….

Are we alone?

While the scale of variation appears excessive and potentially confusing (especially for recruitment), there is a similar situation in other more well-established functions such as finance – with a tendency to categorize/classify jobs and their titles by the nature of the tasks they undertake, eg purchase ledger clerk or accounts receivable etc.

Although at a generic, cross-industry level there are multiple titles, we found an element of industry conformity and to some extent also geographic standards or norms – for example, in the oil & gas industry there are many “contract engineers”, while in the UK (and to a lesser extent the US) “contracts officer” is a common entry position in aerospace and defense, including in the public sector. However, outside defence, other civil servants are typically 'contract managers'.

Title versus Job Role

Looking beyond the title, how much difference is there in the tasks being performed? Job descriptions obviously vary, as does the role of a contracts or commercial function. But essentially there is a high degree of commonality in the work that needs to be performed. Descriptions and titles are translated down through the operating models embedded in the organization. Influencing factors include examples such as:

  • where do contracts and commercial staff report? For example, when embedded in a business unit, they tend to be more focused on business enablement, whereas within Legal or Finance there is greater emphasis on compliance.
  • is there a split between pre-award and post-award contracting activities? When consolidated, there tends to be a greater focus on value delivery. When separated, the groups are often seen as more administrative.
  • is contracts and commercial activity conducted through an integrated buy/sell team, or do these headline functions operate in different spaces and report through to different executive directors (eg CFO buyside and COO sell side)?
  • is the function centralized, center-led/hub and spoke, or a fully devolved model? With the centralized approach it is more likely to operate with greater discipline in titles and career path, whereas more devolved models are accompanied by greater diversity.

Ultimately, a lack of conformity in job titles across industries and geographies does not much matter so long as the individuals themselves operate with reasonably consistent knowledge and methods. Without this consistency, career opportunities are limited since the transition between industries, geographies and perhaps even between companies is often risky for both the individual and the employer. That is a major reason for IACCM's development and promotion of professional certification standards, raising the status and performance of contract and commercial practitioners no matter what their title may be!


Related Discussions

Please sign in or register to post on this forum

2019-06-13 06:49:19

Procurement and Purchasing

Hi all, Can we have a clear explanation for the differences between the terms of Procurement and Purchasing, and also the right position of the Supply Chain, is it a p...
Replies: 4

Allianz Technology
2017-06-06 07:06:35

Performance of Contract Management

I'm curious to get inputs about the performance assessment of contract management. While other roles have defined metrics (for instance, procurement roles can be meas...
Replies: 3
2016-07-11 02:02:35

disadvantages of Pass-through Cost

Can anyone tell me the disadvantages of having more than 50-60% Pass-through Cost when a company is executing a ERP implementation project and is acting as system inte...
Replies: 3
2015-01-27 10:15:01

What is Your Agenda or Contention with Contract Management

The above bullet points are currently a source of contention in the corporate office. The problem is that those that do not have a day-to-day touch point do not under...
Replies: 4

PRS for Music
2019-06-13 09:28:40

Customer survey

Hi, my colleagues and I are putting together a survey for our stakeholders and suppliers. the Objective is to gauge the standard of service and engagement and identify...
Replies: 1

General Electric
2019-02-11 10:18:29

Does a Contract/Commercial Manager require a Law Degree?

Hello All, I have been working as a Commercial Manager for 6.5 years, responsible preparation and negotiation commercial contracts for high value complex transactions(...
Replies: 6

2019-01-16 19:36:14

Contracts Dept or Team Branding Project

Hello, Our contracts department has been tasked with a team branding project. At a basic level, this entails identifying who we are as an organization, what we do, t...
Older entries »
Replies: 3