Can business ever act morally?

Published: 10 Sep 2018 Average Rating: unrated Print

Author: Tim Cummins

The Royal Commission on Financial Services in Australia continues to unearth unprincipled and sometimes illegal activity within many of the industries leading players. These include the enormous scale of commissions paid for the sale of useless products.

In Sweden – yes, the land of ethical leadership – a former General Counsel is on trial for using bribes to win business in Uzbekistan. In the US, a pillar of society is accused of fomenting drug dependencies and seeking to benefit from the invention of an expensive remedy.

No matter where you turn, the stories of malpractice abound. Has it always been this way? The answer is surely yes, but today there is much greater exposure and stories that once were local are now global.

So on one level, you might say that things today are better because at least we know more about what is going on and there is some degree of accountability. Yet is that enough? Will society in general simply shrug its shoulders, or is this undercurrent of unethical business behavior eroding public trust to such a point that it threatens social structure?

These are big questions and I pose them on this blog because it might be argued that it is the duty of the modern commercial function (and each professional within it) to challenge the practices that lead to these unethical activities. In some instances, we have become part of the game. There are certainly lawyers who take the view that it is not so much about doing the right thing, but rather doing the things you can get away with. Procurement functions, when measured on savings, are too often complicit in manipulating the system to meet their measurements rather than the business interest. Contract managers may observe underlying dishonesty in the claims or commitments being made, even sometimes questionable payments, but do they question, or do they turn a blind eye?

Of course, one answer is ever greater levels of regulation, but is that really where we want to go? What sort of world will that create? Another view might be that since most of the unethical practices in business occur in the setting up and management of trading relationships, commercial staff are in a unique position to observe them. The big question, therefore, is what role might we play to raise the integrity of business dealings?


Related Discussions

Please sign in or register to post on this forum
2017-08-23 09:33:18


Dear House, How can a Party demonstrate WILLFUL MISCONDUCT of the other (defaulting) Party. What are the evidences required to make recovery for damages accruing from ...
Replies: 2

2019-05-02 18:43:19

How does your company assign contracts for review?

I am trying to gather information as to how other companies assign contract reviews to their legal/contract teams? Do you assign sequentially? Do you have one person ...
Replies: 3

Occidental Petroleum Corporation
2019-02-12 17:17:02

Cloud Contracting

I am interested in perspectives on various issues and contracting approaches for the use of cloud services, particularly from niche providers who may, in-turn, actuall...
Replies: 1

National Australia Bank
2019-01-25 05:41:53

NPS as a service level

I've recently been asked to explore introducing a new service level to measure our employees' NPS rating of one of our technology suppliers. Given NPS is a s...
Replies: 2
2019-01-03 10:38:17

ADVICE NEEDED: difficult contract management position - customer & shareholder contracts

Hi, My company outsources key services to another company (Company X). However, we also own a portion of Company X as it was set up as a joint venture. I am the contr...
Replies: 3

Ontario Power Generation
2018-10-16 16:37:27

Key Performance Indicators for contract/commercial management group

Would appreciate if any one can share how you measure the success of your company's contract management program/process and/or your commercial management group.
Replies: 2
2018-08-09 19:51:57

Bankrupt Customer; Principles Formed a New Company

Happy Thursday Everyone! Hope you are all doing well. Hoping to receive some guidance and speaking points on a request I recieved from my sales folks. We complete...
Older entries »
Replies: 2