Contracts and 'a free lunch'

Published: 06 Jun 2019 Average Rating: 2.7 / 5 Print

Author: Tim Cummins

Contract performance can be undermined by strange and unpredictable factors. Such is proving to be the case in the A$50bn project to build a new fleet of submarines for the Australian Navy.

The contract was awarded to the Naval Group, a French company, in 2016, after a lengthy bidding and negotiation process that involved a number of international competitors. While there will eventually be substantial work undertaken in Australia, the early phases of the program have involved the relocation of Navy and Defence personnel to north west France. And, according to the Australian Broadcasting Corporation, they are not happy, with 'numerous frustrations' causing growing conflict with the supplier.

Understanding risk

Any good risk analysis will anticipate tensions in the performance of a long term contract. Indeed,  I know from conversations at the time that 'cultural factors' were considered during the award process for this particular program. However, no one expected such apparently minor issues as lunch habits and timeliness of meetings to become major friction points.

“The Australians need to understand the sanctity of the lunch break”, explained Naval Group's French program director, recognizing that “Not everyone thinks like the French”. Communication challenges have been exacerbated by irritants such as a lack of punctuality ('diplomatic lateness') and the traditional French 'shut-down' for the month of August.

In reality, none of this should be a surprise and the Australian Defence Department, more than most, ought to be equipped to deal with such challenges. As one of the earliest and most successful adopters of Relational Contracting, the DoD is fully aware of the critical importance of a formal 'communications protocol', which is once again emerging as a solution in this case. “The staff will learn how to communicate, hold meetings and work in French-Australian teams”, explained the head of HR, recognizing the importance of training in both communication and behavior.

Dealing with the unexpected

A key lesson from this situation is that no risk register can realistically anticipate every issue and nor would it be efficient even to try. However, what can be anticipated is that there will be unexpected events and that there must be formal and agreed mechanisms for their resolution. Whether or not such mechanisms are embedded into the contract, or simply operate as a mutually agreed and documented protocol, is not important. What is essential is that the parties have the maturity and attitudes needed to establish and maintain collaborative working and that they use the disciplines associated with good contracting to define and agree the managerial and operational mechanisms that will underpin a sustainable relationship.

A communication protocol is one of the nine key tenets of IACCM's relational contracting model and workshops, used successfully in a growing range of complex contracts and relationships within both Government and private sector projects. The Australian Department of Defence was one of the early adopters of this model, now used successfully in multiple programs.


Related Discussions

Please sign in or register to post on this forum
2019-01-03 10:38:17

ADVICE NEEDED: difficult contract management position - customer & shareholder contracts

Hi, My company outsources key services to another company (Company X). However, we also own a portion of Company X as it was set up as a joint venture. I am the contr...
Replies: 4

Marshall Denning
2019-06-12 10:55:59

8 payment schemes

Jacko mentions there are 8 different payment schemes - do we know which?
Replies: 1

Occidental Petroleum Corporation
2019-02-12 17:17:02

Cloud Contracting

I am interested in perspectives on various issues and contracting approaches for the use of cloud services, particularly from niche providers who may, in-turn, actuall...
Replies: 2
2019-02-12 17:03:56

Limitation of Liability

I was recently having coffee with four other individuals involved in contracting for IT Professional Services. During the course of conversation one of the participan...
Replies: 3

Rogers Communications
2018-12-06 17:48:18

Source Code Escrow Type Protection for non-software

I am brainstorming ideas for a supplier contract where I want to ensure the technology and services to be provided by the supplier for resale to our end-customer over ...
Replies: 2
2018-10-12 14:32:00


A great article. Roles and responsibilities are often overlooked. We instead, as a buying organisation, like to define how something should be delivered.
Replies: 3

2018-09-18 09:34:19

How to handle a dominating client?

Thanks for the interesting article. From my experience, i've encountered number of client who likes to dominate the contract administration and project execution ...
Replies: 1
2018-01-06 22:53:15

Exception on a NDA

Hi everyone, I have, like Vladimir Koval, a question regarding the Non- Disclosure Agreement. Imagine the following situation: you have to issue a standardized Non-...
Older entries »
Replies: 5