Loading...
 
 

A wake-up call for contract and commercial management

Published: 03 Apr 2014 Average Rating: unrated Print
 

Author: Tim Cummins

If it costs over 500 million Euros, it's a Megaproject. An awful lot of them - some 65% - go wrong, substantially overshooting on budget or experiencing major delay. And since governments worldwide are expected to spend around 100 trillion euros on such projects over the next 15 years, their performance really matters.

Yesterday I attended a Megaproject conference where delegates – mostly academics – were pooling research aimed at understanding how success rates can be improved. The trouble is, we don't really seem to know. And to the extent we do know, it appears better commercial management lies at the core.

 

Until now, the problems affecting megaproject performance have been perceived largely as issues for project management. However, the evidence – thin though it is – appears to point more towards weaknesses in stakeholder analysis, relationship definition, coordination and management. These are capabilities that should be provided through commercial skills and addressed through effective contracting structures and management.

 

Specifically, the major findings from research have been:

 

  • A need for 'special purpose entities' (SPEs). Essentially this is about defining the best relationship model for the project and structuring the organization for its delivery. An SPE is generally a newly structured company or joint venture.
  • A need for 'modularization'. This is essentially about work breakdown and may take several forms, but is especially relevant in addressing some of the more common contract management issues, such as disagreement over scope and goals or contention over change management. Modularization could affect how and where work gets done; but it is executed through separation of contracts and might (I believe) include the type of 'modularization' one would see in agile contracting.
  • Impact of external stakeholders. This is an area that should be very familiar to any commercial manager – the need for thorough stakeholder analysis and reconciliation of their views. Beyond that, in megaprojects, consideration of external stakeholder needs may generate creative ideas for additional value; it will certainly influence how the project is presented, its value proposition and, therefore, will potentially alter scope and goals.
  • Establishing effective performance criteria and management. The business model for megaprojects varies. The criteria that need to be managed also vary – for example, the duration, the likelihood of cost overruns or delays. But in these complex environments, there need to be more measures than the traditional time, cost and quality. For example, behavioral characteristics or agile budgeting might be examples of additional areas requiring active management, as well as the characteristics identified as elements of relational contracting.

Professor Naomi Brookes provided valuable insight when she observed that the ideas being applied in the structuring and management of megaprojects are mostly decades old and never truly tested or validated; they were mostly developed for smaller projects; and they tend to be driven by the buyer or funding agency. In other words, without effective research, contract and commercial management will remain an area of guesswork and far too many projects will continue to under-deliver. That is why IACCM is so determined in pushing the research agenda and raising the skills and competencies within member organizations. It is time for the practitioner community to awaken to the scale of need and opportunity that this represents and to become far more active in support and advocacy of improved commercial and contracting standards. 

 

Comment or read more of Tim's blog

 
 
 

Related Discussions

Please sign in or register to post on this forum

STC Solutions
2020-08-27 12:28:02

Procurement

very in interesting subject
 
 
Replies: 1

Dstl
2020-08-12 06:46:49

The end of Procurement

Hello Tim I found your article very interesting. I agree that procurement struggled for years to prove its real value, and it is still struggling. Firstly. Until the ...
 
 
Replies: 1

KEO International Consultants
2020-05-26 13:02:59

Negotiation effectiveness

What are the fundamentals and effective tools to be taken into consideration before negotiation meetings. Please share negotiation cases initiated from both parties. I...
 
 
Replies: 1

Airbus Defence and Space GmbH
2020-05-25 10:22:15

Call for Help for Contract Innovation in the Defence and AeroSpace Industry for the DASI

Dear All, first of all I hope you are all doing good considering the challenging times. Airbus as most large corparations has initiated and started an internal inno...
 
 
Replies: 1
Anonymous
2020-04-07 01:47:23

Manufacturing capacity

Where will the extra manufacturing capacity come from to make goods to combat Covid 2019?
 
 
Replies: 1

Seplat Petroleum Development Company Plc
2020-03-30 21:29:36

Legal department approach to risk

I have been having a running battle with the legal department in the company where I work for over nine months, on the need to have a simplified contract document o...
 
 
Replies: 1

Toronto transit commission
2020-03-27 15:19:59

Commercial Management Structure, Model, and Governance in Public Sector

Hi Everyone; Hope you and your loved ones are doing well and staying safe! We are in the process of Commercial Management Function establishment. We do have Materia...
 
 
Replies: 1

NXB AB
2019-12-17 11:22:11

Agenda 2030 and public procurement driving it

Lately, I have come across strong initiatives in the Nordic countries that intend to drive Agenda 2030 and all it´s goals by embedding the content within the public pr...
 
 
 
 
 
Replies: 4

Pretorius Consulting
2019-09-18 17:50:21

Pricing Article Changes

Does anyone actually price changes to the Articles of the contract? For example, changing the venue for arbitration (5% of the contract value) or the change order pro...
 
 
 
 
Older entries »
Replies: 3